Physics Faculty

Physics Home

School of Science

Behrend College
 

  Darren Williams - Chaotic Orbital Evolution of Two Closely-Spaced Planets


Newton said that all objects in the universe exert a gravitational force on all other objects. Thus, the Sun exerts a gravitational pull on the Earth, but so does the Moon and all of the planets within the Solar System.  The degree that a planet is affected by the multitude of forces exerted on it depends on the masses and distances of the objects doing the pulling, as well as the planet's own mass. The motion of the Earth is governed primarily by the Sun - we say that the Earth is in orbit around the Sun - and, to a smaller degree, by the Moon and the other planets, despite the close proximity of these lesser bodies. If the gravitational pull from the other planets in the Solar System were hypothetically removed, Earth would orbit the Sun on a path which would remain unchanged for as long as the Sun existed. But with the other planets present, Earth's near-circular orbit is gravitationally perturbed so that the shape and orientation of its orbit gradually change over time. Despite these changes, Earth's orbit within the Solar System is remarkably stable, and will continue to be for billions of years.  

Earth-like planets around other stars may not be as fortunate if the neighboring planets in their systems are larger or more closely spaced than the planets in the Solar System. All of the planets recently detected around nearby stars are Jupiter-mass planets (~300 Earth masses) orbiting within what is the terrestrial-planet region of our own Solar System. Around the star 70 Virginis in the constellation Virgo, for example, is a planet  more than 7-8 times the mass of Jupiter and closer to its star than Venus is to the Sun (~65 million miles or 0.7 AU; an AU, or astronomical unit, is the distance between the Earth and the Sun, or ~93 million miles). The highly eccentric (noncircular) orbit of the large planet around 70 Virginis is shown in dark blue in the above figure. The star 70 Virginis is located at the figure origin. Whether any additional planets, big or small, are present around 70 Virginis is unknown at this time.  

Could there be an Earth in this system? The orbital integration software available at Behrend College is an ideal tool for answering such questions because the user can easily customize arbitrarily simple or complex systems of gravitationally interacting bodies and put them into motion to investigate possible dynamic outcomes. For the simulation pictured above, a 10 Jupiter-mass planet was placed in an eccentric orbit (e = 0.40) at 0.47 AU from its star to represent the giant planet recently discovered around star 70 Virginis. A second planet of ~ 1 Earth mass was placed in an approximately circular orbit (e ~ 0) at 1.0 AU, and inclined by 5 degrees relative to the first. The two-planet system was then integrated over 1 million years. The orbital evolution of the Earth-sized planet is shown in red in the above figure. For clarity, only ~60 of the more than 1 million Earth orbits are shown. Large scale changes in the shape and orientation of lesser planet's orbit bring it closer and closer to the extremely stable orbital path of the giant planet. Once the orbital paths of the two planets cross in the not-too-distant future, the two planets will experience a close encounter resulting either in the destruction or ejection of the smaller planet. This dramatic result suggests that there can be no Earth-sized planets this close to the giant planet known to orbit 70 Virginis.  
  

Any comments or complaints about this material can be sent to dmw145@psu.edu

 
 
 

The Pennsylvania State University ©1996-99
Copyright Statement
This page was created and is maintained by Isaac Hagenbuch
Updated July 27, 1999